Skin Care

Do Scar Treatments Really Work? We Rate the Best Scar Removal Creams

Beautiful woman's body with scar on waist
Scars can easily cause you a headache, requiring intensive makeup to cover them, complicating your daily schedule, while they can make you feel embarrassed, affecting your self-esteem and everyday life.

The great news is that there are quality solutions on the market, which can lessen the symptoms, restoring your confidence.

You can forget those DIY scar removal creams, and focus on quality products, and solutions for all needs: scar removal lotion on legs, cream on face, gel on a tattoo and much more. Let’s see the top picks for how to lighten scars!

Best Scar Removal Creams Without a Prescription

badge-1
badge-2
badge-3
Top Seller!
Best Value!
Extra Strength!
Scar Away
CELSUS
Mederma Advanced
Mederma_ASG_Box
Effectiveness: 5 out of 5
Effectiveness: 4.5 out of 5
Effectiveness: 4.0 out of 5
Value: 4.5 out of 5
Value: 5.0 out of 5
Value: 4.5 out of 5
Our Overall Rating
5stars
5 out of 5 stars
Our Overall Rating
5stars
4.5 out of 5 stars
Our Overall Rating
5stars
4 out of 5 stars

#1. Scar Away Scar Repair Gel

scar-away

Pros:

  • Quick and easy to apply

Cons:

  • Does not dry quickly
The Kelo-cote silicone technology enables Scar Away’s Scar Repair Gel to dry within minutes, forming a sheet over the area. This special gel softens and flattens the scars, while it also reduces redness or discoloration, and provides relief for itch and pain. As the gel is odorless and breathable, it is suitable for all ages, even for children or for the ones with sensitive skin. When applied as an acne scar removal night cream, it’s 100% breathable.

Once the gel is applied, it acts as a second layer of skin, providing you with 24-hour efficiency. The product has been clinically proven, while it also received numerous positive customer feedback on Amazon.

As it is wearable under makeup, it provides a versatile and comfortable solution, while it seems to be the best scar removal night cream alternative. However, the gel does not dry as quick as promised, therefore, when planning your morning schedule, calculate with an extra 10-20 minutes for the gel to dry.


#2. CELSUS Bio-Intelligence Scar Cream with Peptides


Pros:

  • Great for treating scars, stretch marks and much more

Cons:

  • Healing process can be slow
The bio-intelligent scar cream from Celsius comes with more than 20 ingredients, which are activated and utilized when applied to the affected area, delivering an enhanced result by relying on the Peptide technology. Besides Tamanu, Gotu Kola, Helichrysum, MSM, CoQ10, the cream contains numerous anti-aging, regenerative and moisturizing ingredients, which also delivers an anti-oxidant effect.

The ingredients used are natural, enabling you to use the gel on a daily basis, without clogging any pores. It can be easily applied, and it is 100% wearable under makeup, while the natural ingredients ensure that it is suitable for all ages. The product comes with a “no questions asked, 100%” refund policy, making this particular gel a smart choice on the market.

In case you are wondering that: “what is the best lotion for stretch marks?” Well, the bio-intelligent gel from Celsus is not only effective against scars, acne scars or burns, but it can also be used for stretch marks and even for anti-aging. On the other hand, your desired result might only come after months, therefore, if you are after a quick solution, CELSUS’s gel might not be the best pick for you.


#3. Revitol Scar Removal Cream


Pros:

  • Treats all kinds of scars

Cons:

  • Scar removal cream side effects (breakout)
Revitol’s Scar Removal Cream promises to be your next quality solution for acne scars, scars caused by surgery, cut scars, gashes and bruises, and even for sun damage. This scar removal cream can even reduce the appearance of scars as much as 20 years old! The natural ingredients ensure that even the ones with soft skin can use this specific removal cream. This is the all-in-one solution: scar removal cream on face, and for all body parts, while it even helps with sun damage.

Use the cream 2-3 times a day, apply a small amount of the gel on the affected area to get your result. The only possible drawback of Revitol’s solution is that if the gel is used on a regular basis can cause skin breakouts – especially if not the correct amount of gel is applied to the affected areas.

However, if you keep an eye on your daily gel dosage and give your skin a day to breathe every once in a while, this might be the perfect cream that you are after.


#4. Mederma Scar Cream Plus SPF 30

Pros:

  • Great for sun protection and scar softening

Cons:

  • Does not cure scars 100%
Mederma, one of the best and most recommended brand for scars, brings you a scar protection/treatment solution. While the cream has been clinically proven to reduce discoloration, it also protects against sunburns, making your scar less noticeable. Scar Cream Plus also improves the appearance, softness, and texture of the scars. As sun exposure can further darken your scars,

As sun exposure can further darken your scars, Maderma’s cream focuses on Sun protection and scar treatment. After 4, or 5 days of regular usage, you will surely see the result that you were after, while you can enjoy the extra protection by Mederma. While Scar Cream Plus SPF is considered to be an all-around solution for all types of scars, it is much more focused on sun protection and burns scar treatment, therefore when applying it specifically for acne scars, it does not deliver a 100% result.

Provided you are after a scar removal gel on a tattoo, Mederma’s Cream Plus SPF30 is highly recommended!


#5. Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel

Pros:

  • Works great for scars

Cons:

  • Dries slowly
It has been clinically proven that this gel flattens and softens scars over time, while it also reduced the redness of the area. As it is 100% silicone you can easily apply it under make-up, creating an additional layer, that, cleaning the affected area and helping to hide any unwanted scars.

Apply it twice a day for the maximum result and give some time for the healing process to take place. The gel also helps to relieve itching, pain or any discomfort associated with scars. Once again, as this is a silicone product, you should be prepared for additional drying times of 10-20 minutes before the gel would dry fully.


#6. bioCorneum plus SPF 30 Advanced Scar Supervision

Pros:

  • FDA-cleared scar treatment

Cons:

  • Can irritate your eyes
This is the one and only silicone scar treatment solution with SPF that has been FDA-cleared. It softens and flattens the scars, while reduces redness and discoloration. The Advanced Scar Supervision also relieves any itch or discomfort associated with your scar, while it also delivers UV protection, protecting the area from discoloration or redness.

The only negative feature of the Advanced Scar Supervision is that it can irritate your eye, causing eye redness. If the gel needs to be applied around your eyes, pay attention when applying it.


#7. Best Scar Cream for Acne Scars

Pros:

  • Award-winning quality product

Cons:

  • No sunblock effect (additional purchase is required for successful treatment)
The “Best Scar Cream,” or the InvinCible Scars Gel fades scars and darkens spots, to help you cover any affected area until the end of your scar treatment. The gel should be applied daily, for at least 12 weeks, which consists of Vitamin C and dimethicone silicone, delivering an effective result with combined ingredients. InvinCible Scars can also be applied to other types of hyperpigmentation, like skin injury, sun exposure, acne, or burn scars.

As it consists of silicone, you can wear it under your makeup, while it is also 100% natural, to ensure safe daily appliance. This acne scar removal herbal cream has won several awards, which makes a professional, high-quality choice. Apply it at least twice a day, together with any other sunblock product to achieve the maximum result.


Hopefully, you have found the perfect pick in the list above. To make sure that we cover everything regarding scar removal, below you can find a few common questions and answers, that might provide additional help in picking the right product:

What are the different types of scars?

To identify the perfect treatment for your scars, it is extremely important to know what type of scar you are dealing with:

  1. Keloid scars are the result of an overly aggressive healing process, which extends beyond the original injury. To prevent keloid scars from developing, use pressure treatment, or silicone based gels during your injury. In more severe cases, surgery, or cryotherapy can be an alternative solution.
  1. In case you have had acne before, you probably know that it can cause scars, which are hard to treat and get rid of. By choosing the right product, you can reduce your itching and treat acne scars efficiently.
  1. Contracture scars are the result of skin burns. They usually tighten the skin, while they can also go much deeper, causing severe pain.
  1. Hypertrophic scars are red scars which do not go beyond the boundary of your injury. This is usually caused by inflammation and the most common treatment for it is either steroids or silicone sheets that can help flatten your scar. Look for silicone-based gels in these cases.

Are over the counter scar removal creams safe?

As our list above has proved, most creams are scientifically proven, vetted products, which rely on natural elements, to deliver maximum efficiency. Therefore, they can be the perfect solution for your specific needs, however, if you are dealing with fresh scars, always consult your doctor before starting a scar treatment.

Do scar removal creams really work?

In short: Yes! However, it is crucial to pick the right type of scar removal cream, as different products focus on various kinds of scars. Also, keep in mind that this is a “treatment.” Therefore, you will be only getting those results by applying creams daily for a longer period (usually months).

Does scar removal cream work on stretch marks?

There are products which can also be used for stretch marks. Before making a purchase, always check the description of the product for any information on stretch mark treatment. CELSUS Bio-Intelligence Scar Cream with Peptides (from our list above) is one of these creams, give it a try!

Does Mederma work on old stretch marks?

Mederma is a family of products, which includes Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy, which was specifically developed to treat stretch marks. This product can be used as a preventive step, but it can also treat older stretch marks.

Ellie

My name is Ellie and I love all the latest beauty, fashion and hair trends. My blog covers anything from social media, product reviews & how-to guides. If you’re anything like me and struggle for spare time hopefully you’ll find my tips save you time and money.

2 Comments

  1. In July I dropped my hair straightener on my ankle causing a serious burn. Once it became a scar, it was very dark & purple. A doctor told me about dermalmd scar serum and I ordered this serum at the end of July & apply it every night after the shower & it is almost completely gone! I am very happy with the serum because I never thought it would go away! 10/10 recommend!

Leave a Response